By Vanessa Hua
©2007 San Francisco Chronicle
February 27, 2007
Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton's presidential campaign excluded reporters for
the Bay Area's two largest ethnic newspapers from a fundraiser Friday at the
Sheraton Palace Hotel -- a perceived snub that led to days of harsh coverage.
"Our main concern is open access for Chinese media and other ethnic media
in this presidential campaign," said Joyce Chen, news editor for Sing Tao, a
daily published in Chinese. "We stand by our commitment to serve our readers
and our community, which often lack access from government and exposure from
mainstream English (language) media."
Readers in the Chinese community have an intense loyalty to Sing Tao and
the World Journal, said Sandy Close, head of New America Media, a national
ethnic media coalition based in San Francisco.
"If they're disrespected by a candidate, no matter what the security
conditions, space requirements and pressures they were under, (campaign
officials) should move to remedy it immediately," said Close, who counseled the
Clinton campaign when it sought her advice this weekend. "If they move quickly,
they can use it to build a bridge, not burn a bridge."
Reporters from Sing Tao and Chinese-language daily World Journal, as well
as the smaller China Press were denied entry to the noon fundraiser.
It turned out that the three papers had not been included in the mailing
list for a press advisory sent out two days ahead that instructed media
representatives to check in by 11:45 a.m. World Journal reporter Portia Li said
she arrived about 10 minutes before noon.
Li, a prominent journalist who has worked for more than two decades in the
Bay Area, said she knew such events routinely begin late and that reporters
often are allowed in after they start.
But a staffer told her she was too late to get in. When Li argued, the
staffer explained that because she was considered "foreign media" -- which
were limited to a single pool reporter -- she could not go in.
Any local media who checked in by the cutoff were admitted.
When Li showed her business card, the staffer asked for two forms of
identification, which seemed to Li to be insulting. She said she had never had
to show identification at similar events.
"She kept saying this is only open for local media, not foreign press," Li
said. "I told her, I'm not foreign press. I'm local media. I was really angry.
It's not about myself. It's about how the mainstream looks at Chinese (people)
as a whole. Why do they call us foreigners, even when we have a local address
on our business card?"
Readers of ethnic media turn to such publications for their emphasis on
issues relevant to their community, Li said. That's why she wanted to cover the
fundraiser herself, rather than have her paper run a story from the
foreign-media pool or from a mainstream American wire service, which is what it
ended up doing.
World Journal was founded in Taiwan and Sing Tao was founded in Hong Kong,
but both have substantial Bay Area and national editions.
After Li left, she called local Chinese civil rights leaders and
Democratic leaders for their take. They in turn called Clinton's campaign, and
another staffer reiterated the check-in policy to Li by phone from Washington, D.C.
After World Journal and other Chinese media ran stories about being
excluded, the campaign apologized.
"It's important for people running the campaign to understand there are a
lot of ethnic papers here that serve the ethnic community. You can't just look
at them and see them as different," said Likcon Lam, editor in chief of Ming
Pao, the Bay Area's third-largest Chinese-language paper.
Ming Pao's reporter and photographer were on the original press list and
were allowed in around 11:45 a.m. The campaign based the list on its own
research and requests from outlets to be included.
Clinton's campaign has pledged to improve its press list and promises that
Clinton will meet with Chinese-language media and Asian Americans during her
next Bay Area visit.
"There's still frustration and hurt feelings, and we're doing our best to
take care of that," spokesman Mo Elleithee said Monday.