Welcome to Asian American Empowerment

Register on the home page for full site privileges.

Sections
Academia
Books
Coolies
Dating
Families
Hate
History
Identity
Law
Leaders
Media
Music
Politics
Society
Theatre


Navigation
Home

Search



In the Chat Room
Users1



In the Forum
 Start new topics on the new forum
 NASA Scientist Arrested For Espionage
 Relic hunters descend on US, European museums
 Nicolas Cage’s ‘Treasure’ buried in debt
 AM kicks WM's ass in schoolfight
 Confucianism and Marxism
 insider trader
 on remake of Sideways

Go to the Forum


Search




Login
Nickname

Password

Security Code:
Security Code
Type Security Code

Don't have an account yet? You can create one. As a registered user you have some advantages like theme manager, comments configuration and post comments with your name.


Send a Postcard
Do your part to spread Asian American awareness by sending this postcard to your friends! Part of a series.

Read More and Comment


Get Our News Feed
Add even fresher Asian American content to your Web site! Just click here for HTML code you can cut and paste into your site to generate a live feed of our most recent headlines.

Click here to see how the live feed will appear on your site.

Or click here for an RSS feed.



  
Vang Case Shows Race Relations Are Not Just Black and White
Posted by Andrew on Thursday, November 10 @ 10:00:00 EST
Hate By Alice L. Chang
©2005 Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel
November 7, 2005

Frank Wu, dean of the Wayne State University Law School, spoke Monday at Marquette University and the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee on "Race Beyond Black and White: Asian Immigrants and the Criminal Justice System." The lectures came on the eve of today's sentencing of Chai Soua Vang, the Hmong-American hunter convicted of killing six white deer hunters in Sawyer County last year. Wu, who has taught at Howard, Columbia and Stanford universities, and whose articles have appeared in the Washington Post and the Chicago Tribune, spoke with Alice L. Chang of the Journal Sentinel staff last week.

Q. Why is the Chai Soua Vang case important?

A. The Vang case has exposed long-simmering tensions that all of us should care about. We have ideals in this nation about belonging, equality and justice. This is a case in which the actions of a single person have been interpreted as the actions of an entire community, in which tragedy has led to further backlash. There's a threat that it will upset a delicate balance we try to strike between welcoming newcomers, especially refugees who've served our nation, and ensuring that we have a core common culture that guides conduct. Vang's case is about the acceptance of the Hmong community and the place of Asian-Americans. One question was, "Did Vang belong on the land where tragedy unfolded?" The broader question is, "Do Asian immigrants belong in the U.S., in the Midwest, or as hunters, as people who can participate in a quintessentially American activity?"

Q. Some have criticized the fact that the jury was all white. But the jury foreman has said that race was not a factor in deliberations. What do you think?

A. (The) jury was not a jury of his peers. If you don't have the experience of being called chink, jap, gook, being looked at as if you don't belong, if you don't have the experience of dislocation, having to assimilate, the experience of constantly being made to feel uncomfortable, it's hard to understand how people will react to tense situations. . . . It was an impossible case, even if he were telling the truth.

Q. If Vang were of a different racial or ethnic background, what would've happened?

A. If the case involved a Jew or an African-American, the response would've been very different. There would've been rallies and support. What did most Asian-Americans do? They distanced themselves, saying, "He's not one of us. Mentally, he's got problems. Let's wait and see. Wait for the trial to be done." African-Americans would say, "Let's make sure the trial is fair to begin with." There is no NAACP for Asian-Americans. Asian-Americans often don't stand up and speak out. The other factor is internal. Many Asians are raised in a culture that values harmony, tradition, deference to elders, in which the norm is not to participate in public culture. They're focused on family and their ethnic community.

Asian-Americans don't have a Jesse Jackson, an Al Sharpton. Asian-Americans need to have agitators and activists.

Q. How does this case compare to the O.J. Simpson trial?

A. It's very different. O.J. was acquitted, Vang was convicted. The images are very different. The images of Asian-Americans, including the Hmong, are not images generally of violence, but of nerd, geek, passive. As refugees, it's an image of people who are suffering. The Vang case, in a single moment, changed the image of Asian-Americans, at least in the heartland. Now, suddenly, it's an image of crazy, irrational, gun-toting, dangerous people.

Q. What does America need to know about Asian-Americans?

A. We're part of this country. We're here to stay. We're equals. The Hmong fought heroically for this nation's interests; that's how they got here.

 
Related Links
· More about Hate
· News by Andrew


Most read story about Hate:
Mark Wahlberg's ''Turning Point''



Article Rating
Average Score: 4.66
Votes: 9


Please take a second and vote for this article:

Excellent
Very Good
Good
Regular
Bad




Options

 Printer Friendly Page  Printer Friendly Page

 Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend



"Login" | Login/Create an Account | 6 comments | Search Discussion
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.

No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register

Re: Vang Case Shows Race Relations Are Not Just Black and White (Score: 1)
by GeoffDB on Friday, November 18 @ 03:34:12 EST
(User Info | Send a Message)
Professor Wu stated in his interview:

"Asian-Americans need to have agitators and activists."

Frederick Douglass was onced asked for advice about getting into politics. His response: "Agitate...Agitate"

The reality is even though Chai Soua Vang was probably as guilty as sin for shooting those hunters in cold blood, he probably did not get a fair trial. And, the jury certainly did not consist of his peers. That's a fact.

I applaud Professor Wu for his contributions to American race relations.



Re: Vang Case Shows Race Relations Are Not Just Black and White (Score: 1)
by nitro (webmaster@asianmediawatch.net) on Wednesday, December 14 @ 08:11:38 EST
(User Info | Send a Message) http://www.asianmediawatch.net
Wu wrote "What did most Asian-Americans do? They distanced themselves, saying, "[Vang] is not one of us... There is no NAACP for Asian-Americans. Asian-Americans often don't stand up and speak out."

I can't stand generalizations like this. In fact, when Senator Mee Moua spoke at an NYU A/P/A Studies Program and Institute panel discussion and public forum on the Vang case, she publicly thanked the JACL and OCA for their support of the Hmong American community and noted that JACL and OCA sent representatives during Thanksgiving weekend to provide support including providing advice and training on media relations, formation of a community response committee, monitoring of the case, etc.; recounted her interaction with and support from other APA organizations like AAJA, AALDEF, and NAPAMC when the news broke; and the pan-APA support and solidarity that formed behind the Hmong American community.

Wu is right is saying that this case is about equality and justice and how Americans perceive and treat the greater Hmong/Asian American community based on the actions of a single individual, but simply charactering most Asian/Hmong Americans as "distancing themselves" and a silent minority is not accurate. Fearing backlash and violence, Hmong American community leaders held press conferences to plead for calm and stated that the actions of one individual should not be taken against the Hmong American community or its hunters (and rightly so); to represent themselves as a community of law-abiding citizens; to wait for all the facts of the Vang case to be revealed; and to advocate for a fair trial; and pan-APA support and solidarity was formed. Too bad the *professor* didn't *learn* anything about APA involvement in the issue at the panel, and in this article as he did at the panel, preferred to dwell on generalizations that may have applied in the past. Significant progress has been made and the state of Asian Pacific America continues to improve today.

The NYU panel has a more comprehensive treatment by Sen. Moua, Prof. Wu and other spearkers on this topic and it's available online (see below) with full audio clips. Such generalizations made in the article above aren't balanced by examples of Asian Americans who do speak up, who are active, and who are engaged fighting for our civil rights, coalition-building, and advocacy/activism and it's a disservice to us all. Note that the panel took place in Feb before Vang's trial but the content of the discussion is still relevant.

Feb 18, 2005 panel with complete audio clips

A/P/A Studies Program and Institute
public discussion
A Deeper Look at the Hmong Hunter Incident
http://www.apa.nyu.edu/events/HmongHunter/

(See Section on Audio Archive)



Re: Vang Case Shows Race Relations Are Not Just Black and White (Score: 1)
by nate on Sunday, January 08 @ 15:40:19 EST
(User Info | Send a Message)
Just out of pure curiosity what does this statement mean?

The broader question is, "Do Asian immigrants belong in the U.S., in the Midwest, or as hunters, as people who can participate in a quintessentially American activity?"

I have to admit I'm not very familiar with this case or trial currently, but I do wonder what the meaning of this broader question really is? Why should we prohibit Asian immigrants from participating in "quintessential American activity?"

Perhaps I'm misinterpreting his words, but maybe someone else could shed some light on that statement.



Re: Vang Case Shows Race Relations Are Not Just Black and White (Score: 1)
by Jessfili on Thursday, March 23 @ 11:45:55 EST
(User Info | Send a Message)
"What did most Asian-Americans do? They distanced themselves, saying, "He's not one of us. Mentally, he's got problems. Let's wait and see. Wait for the trial to be done."
-Professor Wu

I agree with this statement, and I think its really a condemnation of the Asian community. That same demonization that happened to Chai Vang could be done to any one of us and I think its up to the AA community, who sees and understands both cultures, to be the origin of interpretations of Asian American current events in the news media, academia, etc. Nobody else should be saddled with the responsibility of explaining Asian American current events except Asian Americans.

Yes, Chai's image is now a public image, the image of a crazed lunatic Asian male. But where is his side of the story ? His side of the story needs to get out to the media before we can even begin to understand what happened.



Re: Vang Case Shows Race Relations Are Not Just Black and White (Score: 1)
by fersnugriniffle (myname@noone.com) on Thursday, February 08 @ 16:49:25 EST
(User Info | Send a Message)
Vang probably was guilty, and he probably was crazy. But the fact that he said they had shot at him first says something, and from what I read at least, it wasn't even really taken into consideration at all. From what I understand about that area, there have been long negative sentiments toward the Hmong community as it was. It would've been nice, especially considering that, if we could've banded together to at least get him a fair trial.


Web site engine\'s code is Copyright © 2002 by PHP-Nuke. All Rights Reserved. PHP-Nuke is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL license.
Page Generation: 0.487 Seconds

Warning: include(foter.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/caase2/public_html/themes/SlashOcean/theme.php on line 87

Warning: include(foter.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/caase2/public_html/themes/SlashOcean/theme.php on line 87

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening 'foter.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/caase2/public_html/themes/SlashOcean/theme.php on line 87