By Vicki Viotti
©2004 Honolulu Advertiser
August 9, 2004
When the Japanese American Citizens League was born 75 years ago, the
citizenship picture for Japanese-Americans was bleak, and growing worse each
year.
"Let's go back to Pearl Harbor," said John Tateishi, executive
director of the league, speaking by phone from its San Francisco headquarters.
"By 1941 there were in California over 100 bills or statutes that
discriminated very openly against Japanese-Americans.
"Chief among them were the alien land laws and the federal law that
prohibited any Japanese immigrant from becoming an American citizen."
Times, of course, have radically changed. The JACL, which tomorrow will
convene its national convention in Honolulu, has seen prospects improve
immeasurably for its core members, who are practicing citizenship at respected
echelons. The keynote speaker at the event's closing banquet on Saturday, for
example, will be Norman Mineta, the nation's transportation secretary.
As an organization, the league is best known in recent decades for its work
in the 1970s and '80s to win reparations for Japanese-Americans who had been
interned or suffered other discriminatory treatment during World War II. That
was a battle that Tateishi helped launch and that the league finally won in
1988.
Although some things may have dropped off the to-do list for the noted
civil-rights organization, others have been penciled in. For one, said member
Mari Matsuda, a visiting law professor at the University of Hawai'i, the JACL
feels a strong tug toward defending Arab-Americans who are in danger of
suffering similar discrimination as a result of terrorism and the Iraq war.
"The JACL has been outspoken on the Patriot Act and immigrant
bashing," she said. "We know what that's like, to have your loyalty
questioned just because of your race."
The league finds itself at a kind of crossroads, the national leaders setting
their sights on social justice for a more general Asian-American community,
particularly the immigrant population.
The Isle chapter, which is hosting the convention, has broadened its agenda
even further.
"The thing that attracted me to the Honolulu chapter was it was starting
to look at other civil-rights issues," said Hawai'i Civil Rights Commission
executive director William Hoshijo.
The Hawai'i group supported Native Hawaiian self-determination and opposed
certain constitutional changes, including a ban on same-sex marriage and
proposals that would diminish protections for criminal defendants.
"It doesn't have to be a racial minority, but anyone who is
disenfranchised or marginalized," said Karen Nakasone, a criminal attorney
newly elected as the chapter president.
At local and national levels, the JACL is facing similar, twin challenges:
drawing the younger generation into its mission and seeing that, in the face of
increasing multiculturalism, the organization doesn't lose touch with its
Japanese cultural roots.
The cultural middle ground inhabited by those of part-Japanese ancestry will
form the basis of one convention forum, a session on the "hapa," or
multiethnic population. One participant, Shayna Coleon, is a fourth-generation (yonsei)
descendant, who believes the concept of what it means to be Japanese-American is
being redefined by the young.
"People tell me I don't look Japanese," she said, "and I
think, what does a Japanese person look like nowadays? Those are all the
barriers we're trying to look at."
Nationally, the organization is worried about an annual membership attrition
of 9 percent, as younger members haven't taken the place of the nisei,
second-generation Japanese Americans, who have been the league's traditional
mainstays.
Locally, there's a similar interest in drawing the young while honoring the
old guard. Susan Kitsu, who just turned over the reins as Hawai'i chapter
president and is chairing the convention, said the nearly four years of planning
for the event began with a discussion of core values, known by the Japanese term
"kachikan."
Among those values: "kansha," or thankfulness, a principle that
directed convention planners to include tributes to war veterans and other
heroes of the past; and "sekinin," or responsibility.
"Adults have responsibility to our youth, which is why we started the
'Aha 'Opio Youth Diversity Summit," Kitsu said, referring to a segment of
the convention that involves youth in discussion of campus hate crimes and other
relevant civil-rights topics.
The national group has had the harder row to hoe in this regard. Tateishi
said the JACL is still working against an "old paradigm" that gives
Asian-Americans short shrift in public policy debates.
"Asians are a footnote in those discussions," he said. "And
even being a footnote would be better than an afterthought, which is what we are
much of the time.
"In California, we're the second-largest minority group, after Latinos,
but we're still running a distant third, after African-Americans, in the minds
of the politicians," Tateishi said.
"We have a very different view of our place in the world than Asians and
Pacific Islanders do in Hawai'i."
The local chapter believes Hawai'i has an experience worth telling an
audience concerned with civil rights, Kitsu said.
"It's one example of how it can work," she said. "I don't
think we are 'it.' I don't think we have 'arrived.' We've got a long way to go.
"But I think we've done a good job of getting along," she said.
"You can see it at our potlucks — all the different kinds of food are on
the table."